kathimerini.gr

Trump Seeks Census Excluding Undocumented Immigrants

Donald Trump requested a new US census excluding undocumented immigrants, potentially altering congressional seat allocation and defying the Constitution's mandate to count all persons; this action could face legal challenges and significantly impact political representation.

Read original article in Greek

Greek

Greece

PoliticsElectionsImmigrationDonald TrumpGerrymanderingUs Census

Us Department Of CommercePew Research CenterRepublican Party

Donald TrumpTerry Ann Lowenthal

What are the immediate implications of Trump's proposal to exclude undocumented immigrants from the US census?: Donald Trump requested a new US census excluding undocumented immigrants, potentially impacting congressional seat allocation and contradicting the Constitution's mandate for counting all persons. This could lead to legal challenges and political disputes, significantly altering political representation.
How might excluding undocumented immigrants from the census affect the allocation of congressional seats and federal funding?: Trump's proposal to exclude undocumented immigrants from the census could shift political power, benefiting states with fewer undocumented immigrants. The Pew Research Center estimates that excluding these individuals in 2020 would have cost some states, like California, a congressional seat. This action potentially violates the US Constitution.
What are the potential legal and constitutional challenges to Trump's proposed census changes, and what are their long-term implications for political representation?: Trump's plan raises concerns about fairness and accuracy in representation. Excluding undocumented immigrants could lead to underrepresentation of minority groups and fuel legal battles over constitutional rights. The long-term effects might reshape the political landscape and deepen existing partisan divides.

Cognitive Concepts

2/5

Framing Bias

The article frames Trump's proposal as a contentious issue, highlighting the opposition from experts and the potential legal challenges. However, it also presents Trump's statements without significant pushback or detailed analysis of their factual basis or implications. The headline could be improved to reflect the controversy more neutrally.

1/5

Language Bias

The article uses relatively neutral language, although phrases like "very expensive census" and "people illegally in our country" could be considered slightly loaded. More neutral alternatives would be "a detailed census" and "undocumented immigrants".

3/5

Bias by Omission

The article omits discussion of potential legal challenges to Trump's proposal, the broader political implications of excluding undocumented immigrants from the census, and alternative solutions for addressing concerns about the accuracy of census data. It also doesn't detail the methods by which the administration would identify and exclude undocumented immigrants.

3/5

False Dichotomy

The article presents a false dichotomy by focusing primarily on the debate between including or excluding undocumented immigrants, without exploring other potential solutions for improving census accuracy or addressing concerns about the process. The presentation implies that these are the only two options.

Sustainable Development Goals

Reduced Inequality Negative

Direct Relevance

Excluding undocumented immigrants from the census, as proposed by Donald Trump, could lead to underrepresentation of minority groups in the apportionment of congressional seats and federal funding, thus exacerbating existing inequalities. This is especially relevant given that the Pew Research Center estimates that several states would have lost congressional seats in 2020 if undocumented immigrants were excluded.

Sep 26, 01:14

AfD Demands stricter citizenship laws and halt to green energy policies in Bavaria

The AfD party in Bavaria is demanding stricter naturalization laws, including reviewing all naturalizations since 2015 and requiring retesting for those naturalized since 2022, alongside a halt to green energy projects and a return to nuclear power and Russian gas imports.

Sep 25, 04:18

VVD

The Dutch VVD party, historically associated with liberalism, faces a potential electoral decline due to policy choices diverging from its core principles, particularly concerning taxation, housing, and immigration.

Sep 23, 04:18

Spanish Government's Immigration Transfer to Catalonia Fails to Secure Congressional Support

A proposed transfer of immigration authority from the Spanish government to Catalonia faces certain defeat in Congress due to opposition from PP, Vox, UPN, and Podemos, highlighting fissures within the governing coalition and potentially escalating tensions between the government and Junts.

Sep 22, 07:22

Spain: Immigration Debate Intensifies Amidst Palestinian Crisis Sympathy

Amidst widespread sympathy for Palestinians, a heated debate over immigration policy is escalating in Spain, particularly concerning a proposed transfer of immigration management powers to Catalonia, which faces potential rejection in a close parliamentary vote.