us.cnn.com
Tubman Removed from "Underground Railroad" Webpage Amidst Broader Government Website Changes
The National Parks Service removed Harriet Tubman's image and quote from its "Underground Railroad" webpage, along with references to enslaved people and the Fugitive Slave Act, replacing them with content emphasizing "American ideals" and "Black/White Cooperation," following similar changes to other government websites under the Trump administration.
- How do the changes to the webpage relate to the broader campaign by the Trump administration to eliminate DEI initiatives, and what are the consequences of this approach to historical interpretation?
- The changes to the National Parks Service webpage reflect a broader pattern of altering historical narratives under the Trump administration. The removal of Tubman, a key figure in the fight against slavery, alongside the downplaying of slavery itself, demonstrates a deliberate attempt to reshape historical interpretations. This aligns with the administration's efforts to eliminate DEI initiatives across government websites.
- What is the significance of removing Harriet Tubman from the National Parks Service's "Underground Railroad" webpage, and what immediate impact does this action have on the public understanding of American history?
- The National Parks Service removed Harriet Tubman's image and quote from its "Underground Railroad" webpage, also removing references to enslaved people and the Fugitive Slave Act. This followed other controversial changes to government websites under the Trump administration, including the removal of LGBTQ+ related content from other sites. The revised webpage now emphasizes "American ideals of liberty and freedom", starting with commemorative stamps of civil rights leaders and the phrase "Black/White Cooperation.
- What are the long-term implications of controlling and altering historical narratives presented on government websites, and how might this approach impact future discussions about American history and social justice?
- The alterations to the "Underground Railroad" webpage are not isolated incidents but part of a larger attempt to control historical narratives and diminish the role of marginalized groups in American history. This control extends beyond the National Parks Service, affecting other institutions like the Pentagon and the Smithsonian. This trend indicates a continued attempt to shape public understanding of American history, likely leading to further controversy and debate.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The changed framing significantly alters the narrative. The original emphasis on enslaved people's agency and the harsh realities of slavery is replaced with a focus on abstract American ideals. This shift, evident in the headline changes and the introductory paragraphs, downplays the struggles faced by enslaved people and presents a more palatable, less challenging historical account. The inclusion of commemorative stamps of various civil rights leaders under the phrase "Black/White Cooperation" further shapes the narrative towards a more harmonious and less conflict-oriented interpretation of history.
Language Bias
The article itself does not display overtly biased language. However, the removal of terms like "enslaved people" and the replacement with more euphemistic language represents a form of language bias by omission, as these changes significantly alter the tone and impact of the narrative. The focus on "Black/White cooperation" also minimizes the systemic oppression inherent in slavery.
Bias by Omission
The removal of Harriet Tubman's image and quote, along with references to enslaved people and the Fugitive Slave Act, constitutes a significant omission of crucial historical context. This omission minimizes the role of enslaved people in their own liberation and distorts the narrative of the Underground Railroad, presenting a sanitized and incomplete picture of this important historical event. The revised emphasis on "American ideals of liberty and freedom" without explicit mention of slavery further exacerbates this bias by omission.
False Dichotomy
The article doesn't explicitly present a false dichotomy, but the removal of content related to slavery and the focus on "Black/White cooperation" could implicitly create a false dichotomy by suggesting a simplistic narrative of racial harmony that ignores the complex power dynamics and struggle for racial justice inherent in the Underground Railroad.
Gender Bias
While not directly exhibiting gender bias in language, the removal of Harriet Tubman, a prominent female figure crucial to the Underground Railroad, constitutes a form of gender bias by omission. Her removal diminishes the important role of women in the fight for freedom and perpetuates a historical narrative that underrepresents female contributions.
Sustainable Development Goals
The removal of Harriet Tubman's image and quote from the Underground Railroad webpage diminishes the recognition of her contributions to the fight against slavery and gender inequality. Tubman, a woman who defied societal norms and risked her life to liberate enslaved people, serves as a powerful symbol of gender equality. Removing her diminishes this representation and undermines the historical narrative of women's strength and resilience in the face of oppression. The focus shift towards "Black/White Cooperation" without acknowledging the context of racial inequality and slavery further marginalizes the experiences and contributions of women who fought for freedom.