dw.com
UN Ocean Conference: High Seas Treaty Nears Ratification Amidst Calls for Deep-Sea Mining Moratorium
The UN Ocean Conference in Nice aims to implement concrete actions for ocean protection, including the soon-to-be-enforced High Seas Treaty, a moratorium on deep-sea mining supported by France and 30 countries, and expanded marine protected areas by the UK.
- What immediate actions are being taken at the UN Ocean Conference to address the critical threats facing the world's oceans?
- The UN's 3rd Ocean Conference in Nice aims to translate decades-long pledges into concrete actions for ocean protection. France announced that the High Seas Treaty, enabling the creation of protected areas in international waters, will soon enter into force after reaching the required 60 ratifications. Currently, only 2.7 percent of the ocean is effectively protected from destructive activities, far short of the 30x30 initiative's goal.
- How do the commitments made at the conference, such as the moratorium on deep-sea mining and the expansion of marine protected areas, connect to the broader goals of the 30x30 initiative?
- The conference addresses critical issues like deep-sea mining, which threatens fragile ecosystems, and plastic pollution. France and 30 other countries advocate for a moratorium on deep-sea mining, highlighting the potential for irreversible damage to biodiversity. The UK pledged to expand its marine protected areas, restricting destructive bottom trawling, while France made a smaller commitment.
- What are the potential long-term implications of failing to achieve the ambitious goals set at the UN Ocean Conference, particularly regarding biodiversity loss and the impacts of climate change?
- The success of the conference hinges on translating commitments into effective enforcement and global cooperation. Germany announced several self-commitments, including cleaning up WWII munitions in the North and Baltic Seas, and supporting developing nations in creating marine protected areas. The upcoming negotiations for a global plastic treaty will be a crucial next step in comprehensive ocean protection.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The article frames the UN Ocean Conference as a crucial turning point for ocean protection, emphasizing the urgency and need for decisive action. The repeated use of words like "rettungsplan" (rescue plan) and the focus on Macron's strong statements contribute to this framing. While this is justified by the urgency of the situation, it could also be interpreted as somewhat alarmist, neglecting the existing conservation efforts and highlighting only the negative aspects. The headline, though not provided, is likely to reinforce this urgent framing.
Language Bias
The article uses strong and emotive language, such as "übersäuert" (over-acidified), "vermüllt" (littered), and "Stresszustand" (stress state), to describe the oceans. While accurately reflecting the severity of the situation, this language could be perceived as alarmist or sensationalist. More neutral alternatives could include terms such as "degraded", "polluted", and "compromised". The use of phrases like "neuen Wilden Westen" (new Wild West) is another example of charged language used to evoke a strong emotional response.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the UN conference and the actions of France and Germany, potentially omitting the perspectives and actions of other significant players in ocean conservation. While mentioning the USA's delayed participation, the article doesn't delve into the reasons for their hesitation or the specifics of their approach to ocean protection. The article also lacks detail on the perspectives of developing nations, whose economies may be heavily reliant on ocean resources, and how they are balancing economic needs with conservation efforts. The potential impact of these omissions is a less complete picture of global efforts and challenges related to ocean conservation.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a somewhat simplistic dichotomy between economic exploitation of the oceans and complete protection. While advocating for a moratorium on deep-sea mining, it doesn't fully explore the potential for sustainable practices that could balance economic development with environmental protection. The presentation of the 30x30 initiative as a simple target without discussing the complexities of implementation and potential trade-offs also contributes to this oversimplification.
Gender Bias
The article primarily features male political leaders and experts. While this reflects the gender imbalance prevalent in high-level political and scientific arenas, the lack of prominent female voices could be perceived as a gender bias by omission. Further analysis of the gender balance among scientists and activists mentioned would be beneficial.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article highlights the UN Ocean Conference aiming to protect the oceans, with a focus on establishing high seas protection areas, reducing deep-sea mining, and phasing out harmful fishing practices. These actions directly contribute to SDG 14 (Life Below Water) by conserving and sustainably using the oceans, seas, and marine resources.