lexpress.fr
UN Ocean Conference: Urgent Action Needed to Protect Degrading Oceans
The third UN Ocean Conference in Nice, France, aims to accelerate global action to protect the ocean, with discussions on deep-sea mining, bottom trawling, and the high seas treaty, despite concerns about the lack of binding commitments and sufficient funding.
- How do the discussions on deep-sea mining and bottom trawling at the conference reflect broader conflicts between economic interests and the need for ocean conservation?
- The conference highlights the alarming degradation of ocean health, with oceans absorbing 90% of excess heat from climate change. While some countries may announce new marine protected areas, aiming for 10% coverage (up from 8.36%), this falls short of the 30% target by 2107, and many current protected areas still allow destructive practices.
- What concrete actions are being taken at the UN Ocean Conference to address the critical threats facing the world's oceans, and what are their immediate implications for marine ecosystems?
- The UN Ocean Conference in Nice aims to address the critical state of the oceans, with 50 heads of state attending, including those from Brazil and France. A non-binding declaration calling for urgent action will be adopted, but concerns remain about its effectiveness, given the absence of the US and a lack of concrete commitments.
- What are the long-term implications of insufficient funding for ocean protection on the ability to achieve the UN's Sustainable Development Goals related to marine ecosystems and climate change?
- Key issues include deep-sea mining, where a moratorium is sought by France and others against the backdrop of a potential July ruling by the International Seabed Authority on a mining code. The lack of funding for ocean protection, currently underfunded by $165 billion annually, is a major obstacle to achieving sustainability goals.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The article frames the UN Ocean Conference as potentially falling short of expectations, emphasizing the concerns of NGOs and highlighting the absence of the US. This framing, while presenting legitimate criticisms, could leave the reader with a pessimistic view of the conference's potential impact. The headline, if it reflected the skeptical tone of the article, would further reinforce this framing. The use of quotes from Greenpeace criticizing the conference as "Belles paroles" and a "coquille vide" further reinforces a negative framing.
Language Bias
The article uses some loaded language, particularly in describing the potential outcomes of the conference (e.g., 'coquilles vides'). While the author attributes these phrases to specific sources (Greenpeace, etc.), the inclusion of such strong criticisms without counterbalancing perspectives could subtly influence reader perception. The repeated use of phrases like 'action urgente' and 'dégrade à une vitesse alarmante' contribute to a sense of urgency and potential crisis, which, while factually accurate, still influences the emotional response of the reader. Neutral alternatives would include more measured language, such as 'significant action is needed' and 'the health of oceans is rapidly deteriorating.'
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the UN Ocean Conference in Nice, but omits discussion of other significant international efforts or initiatives related to ocean conservation. While acknowledging the conference's importance, the lack of broader context might leave the reader with a limited understanding of the global landscape of ocean protection. Additionally, the article doesn't delve into the potential economic impacts of ocean protection measures on various stakeholders.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a somewhat false dichotomy by framing the conference as either a 'rampe de lancement pour des mesures concrètes' or 'un simple exercice de communication'. The reality is likely more nuanced, with the conference potentially leading to some concrete actions while also serving as a platform for communication and awareness-raising. The simplistic framing oversimplifies the complexity of international negotiations.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article discusses the UN Ocean Conference in Nice, focusing on global efforts to protect oceans. The conference aims to create new marine protected areas, address issues like deep-sea mining and bottom trawling, and strengthen the international treaty on high seas protection. These actions directly contribute to SDG 14 (Life Below Water) by improving ocean health and biodiversity.