nos.nl
US Boarding School Death Toll Far Exceeds Government Estimate: 3104 Indigenous Children Died
A Washington Post investigation found that at least 3104 Indigenous children died at US boarding schools between 1828 and 1970, significantly higher than the government's previous estimate of 973, revealing many deaths under suspicious circumstances due to abuse, neglect, and the forced assimilation policy of 'killing the Indian, saving the man'.
- What specific factors contributed to the high death toll at these boarding schools, and how do these factors connect to broader patterns of cultural assimilation and oppression?
- The significantly higher death toll uncovered by The Washington Post demonstrates the severity of abuse and neglect inflicted upon Indigenous children in US boarding schools. The systematic cultural assimilation, enforced through separation from families and suppression of Indigenous languages and traditions, resulted in devastating health and mortality consequences. This systematic suppression is further evidenced by the discovery of 66 additional burial sites beyond those previously identified by the government.
- What are the long-term consequences of the revealed death toll and the broader history of cultural assimilation on Indigenous communities in the US, and what steps are necessary to address the ongoing impact?
- The findings expose a long history of violence and cultural genocide against Indigenous peoples in the US. The substantial disparity between the official count and the actual number of deaths underscores the need for further investigations into these schools, potentially uncovering further evidence of human rights abuses and systemic failures. This could lead to more thorough investigations and potentially reparations for affected families.
- What is the precise number of Indigenous children's deaths uncovered by The Washington Post's investigation, and how does this compare to previous government estimates, highlighting the immediate implications?
- The Washington Post's year-long investigation revealed that at least 3104 Indigenous children died at US boarding schools between 1828 and 1970, far exceeding the government's previous estimate of 973. The discrepancy highlights the systematic undercounting of deaths, many under suspicious circumstances, including documented cases of abuse and neglect.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The framing emphasizes the stark contrast between the government's initial findings and The Washington Post's investigation, highlighting the government's underreporting. The headline and introduction immediately establish this contrast, potentially influencing readers to perceive the government's actions as negligent or even complicit. The article uses strong emotional language like "gruwelijkste hoofdstuk" (cruelest chapter) to underscore the severity of the situation.
Language Bias
The article uses strong language, such as "verdachte omstandigheden" (suspicious circumstances) and descriptions of child abuse and neglect, to emphasize the severity of the situation. While this is appropriate given the subject matter, it could be argued that the tone is emotionally charged and may affect objectivity. More neutral alternatives could include phrases like "deaths under investigation" and "instances of mistreatment.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses on the significantly higher death toll revealed by The Washington Post's investigation compared to the government's report. While acknowledging that the actual number might be even higher due to unmarked graves and lost records, it doesn't delve into potential biases in the government's initial investigation or other contributing factors that may have led to underreporting. The article also doesn't explicitly discuss the long-term societal effects of the assimilation policies on Indigenous communities.
False Dichotomy
The article doesn't present a false dichotomy, but it could benefit from acknowledging potential complexities beyond the sheer number of deaths. For example, the diverse experiences within the schools and variations in treatment across different institutions are not explicitly addressed. The focus remains largely on the overall death toll.
Sustainable Development Goals
The high death toll among Indigenous children at US residential schools, far exceeding previous estimates, indicates a severe lack of care and resources, contributing to poverty and inequality within Indigenous communities. The systematic abuse and neglect contributed to intergenerational trauma and perpetuated cycles of poverty.