nrc.nl
Van Iperen: Democracy's Failure on Climate Change
Roxane van Iperen's "Eigen Planeet Eerst" analyzes the failure of democracy in addressing climate change, blaming a false 'winners vs. losers' narrative fueled by populism and 30 years of neoliberal policies that created passive consumers lacking empathy, proposing a shift towards local community engagement and long-term societal well-being.
- What role does the author attribute to neoliberalism and the rise of populist ideologies in shaping individual attitudes and hindering effective climate action?
- Van Iperen connects this failure to 30 years of neoliberal policies, transforming citizens into passive consumers who believe in individual responsibility, lacking empathy for those struggling. This, combined with the influence of "alt-right," "alt-finance," and resulting "alt-democracy," prevents effective climate action.
- What potential solutions or approaches does Van Iperen propose to overcome the challenges posed by "alt-democracy" and foster a more sustainable and equitable society?
- Van Iperen suggests that restoring a sense of civic responsibility and local community engagement is crucial, counteracting the short-term, self-serving values of globalized markets. She emphasizes the need for a shift towards valuing long-term societal well-being over immediate economic gains, advocating for a more humanistic approach to governance.
- How does Roxane van Iperen explain the failure of democratic systems to effectively address the climate crisis, and what are the key factors contributing to this failure?
- Roxane van Iperen's essay, "Eigen Planeet Eerst," analyzes the failure of democracy to address climate change, arguing that voters are misled by a false "winners vs. losers" dichotomy exploited by populism. This framework obscures the reality that climate change harms everyone.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The review frames the book as a critique of populism and the failure of democracy in addressing climate change. This framing emphasizes the negative aspects of the political system and downplays any potential solutions or positive aspects. The description of the author's arguments as 'knisperende diagnose' (crisp diagnosis) might suggest a sense of certainty that may not be entirely warranted. The use of terms like 'alt-right', 'alt-finance', and 'alt-democracy' might create a pre-conceived notion in the reader, potentially leading to a biased interpretation.
Language Bias
The review uses strong and emotive language to describe the author's work and its implications. For example, terms like 'knisperende diagnose' (crisp diagnosis), 'funest' (fatal), and 'razend tempo' (breakneck speed) carry strong connotations. While this language may be engaging, it could also sway the reader's interpretation of the book. More neutral descriptions could enhance objectivity.
Bias by Omission
The review focuses heavily on the author's analysis of the book, neglecting to provide specific examples from the book itself to support the claims made. The absence of direct quotes or detailed textual evidence weakens the analysis and limits the reader's ability to form an independent judgment. While the summary provides a general overview, crucial details and nuances from the book are omitted, potentially misrepresenting the author's arguments.
False Dichotomy
The review presents a simplified dichotomy between 'winnaars' (winners) and 'verliezers' (losers) as presented in the book, without exploring the complexities and overlaps within these groups. It also presents a dichotomy between local and global values, neglecting the potential for integration or nuanced approaches. This oversimplification could mislead readers into believing the issues are more easily categorized than they are in reality.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article discusses the failure of democracies to adequately address climate change, highlighting how short-term thinking and prioritizing individual gain over collective well-being hinder progress towards climate action. The author uses the metaphor of "cavia