nrc.nl
West Bank Hiking Tours Navigate Obstacles Amidst Political Conflict
Suhail Hijazi's Hike Palestine, operating since 2011 in the Israeli-occupied West Bank, faces increasing challenges from roadblocks and settler violence, restricting access to hiking trails and impacting tourism; despite this, the group continues to offer unique experiences showcasing diverse landscapes and historical sites, including Wadi el-Qelt and Jericho.
- How does the ongoing Israeli occupation of the West Bank directly affect the tourism sector and access to natural landscapes for Palestinians and foreign visitors?
- Suhail Hijazi, founder of Hike Palestine, has been leading hiking tours in the occupied West Bank for over a decade, showcasing the diverse landscapes despite numerous checkpoints and obstacles. His tours attract both Palestinians and foreign residents, though tourism is currently limited due to the ongoing conflict.
- What are the long-term implications of the restrictions on movement and access to natural areas for the Palestinian economy, cultural heritage, and the well-being of the local population?
- The situation remains volatile and unpredictable, as illustrated by the recent closure of the Wadi el-Qelt access point by an Israeli settlement guard. This unpredictability underscores the challenges and risks involved in promoting tourism and accessing natural areas in the occupied territories, potentially hindering economic opportunities and cultural exchange.
- What are the main obstacles and challenges faced by hiking tour guides like Suhail Hijazi in organizing and conducting tours in the West Bank, and how do these obstacles reflect broader political and security issues?
- The increasing number of roadblocks and settler violence on the West Bank significantly impacts Hijazi's ability to conduct tours, forcing route adjustments and cancellations. This highlights the complex interplay between natural beauty and political conflict impacting access to and enjoyment of natural areas.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The narrative frames the hiking experience through the lens of Palestinian challenges, emphasizing obstacles and restrictions imposed by the Israeli occupation. The headline (while not provided) likely reflects this focus, and the introductory paragraph immediately establishes the difficult context. While the natural beauty is described, it is presented within the overarching context of political conflict and its impact on daily life, potentially reinforcing a pre-existing negative perception of the situation for some readers.
Language Bias
The article uses descriptive language that highlights the difficulties of hiking in the region. While not overtly biased, phrases such as "exploded colonist violence" and the description of checkpoints and roadblocks as "obstacles" could be perceived as carrying negative connotations. More neutral phrasing could improve objectivity. For example, "increased settler violence" and "security checkpoints/roadblocks" could be used.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the obstacles faced by hikers in Palestine due to checkpoints, roadblocks, and settlements, but it omits potential perspectives from Israeli settlers or the Israeli government regarding these security measures. The article also doesn't detail the reasons behind the checkpoints and roadblocks, limiting the reader's ability to fully understand the context of the situation. While acknowledging space constraints is important, including even brief counterpoints could improve balanced reporting.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a somewhat simplified view of the conflict, focusing primarily on the difficulties faced by Palestinians while less extensively discussing the Israeli perspective on the security situation and reasons for settlements. It doesn't explore the complex history and ongoing political disputes fully, presenting a potentially unbalanced portrayal of the issues.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article highlights the significant obstacles faced by Palestinians in accessing and enjoying their natural environment due to the Israeli occupation. Roadblocks, settler violence, and restricted movement severely limit the ability of Palestinians to engage in activities such as hiking and tourism, thus hindering their freedom of movement and enjoyment of their natural resources. The presence of Israeli settlements and military infrastructure further exacerbates these restrictions, undermining peace and justice.