lemonde.fr
West Bank Olive Harvest Marked by Violence; Palestinian Cookbook Released
In December 2023, the West Bank olive harvest ended, marked by unprecedented violence against farmers by Israeli settlers, as reported by UN experts; concurrently, chef Fadi Kattan released a cookbook celebrating Palestinian cuisine, while a 10-year-old Gazan girl uses social media to share recipes from food aid.
- What is the significance of the olive harvest in the West Bank being described as the \"most dangerous ever\" by UN experts?
- In December 2023, the olive harvest in the West Bank concluded, described as the \"most dangerous ever\" by UN experts due to colonist violence against farmers. Simultaneously, Franco-Palestinian chef Fadi Kattan released \"Bethlehem: 90 traditional Palestinian recipes,\" showcasing local producers. The book includes a warning that recent conflict may have impacted the businesses mentioned.
- What are the long-term implications of the ongoing conflict for the preservation of Palestinian culinary traditions and agricultural practices?
- The juxtaposition of Kattan's cookbook release amidst a violent harvest season underscores the Palestinian culinary tradition's enduring power as a form of cultural resistance and identity preservation. The stark contrast between the immense popularity of these culinary social media accounts and the dangerous reality facing Palestinian farmers highlights the urgent need for international attention to the ongoing conflict and its impact on Palestinian livelihoods.
- How do Palestinian chefs like Fadi Kattan and young influencers like Renad Attallah utilize social media and cuisine to convey political messages and maintain cultural identity?
- Chef Kattan uses his three restaurants and Instagram (68,000+ followers) to highlight Palestinian cuisine's political significance, emphasizing the effort behind seemingly simple ingredients like olives, which are cultivated despite threats from Israeli settlers. A 10-year-old Gazan girl, Renad Attallah, also uses Instagram (900,000+ followers) to share recipes made from food aid, showcasing resilience.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The article frames the Palestinian experience primarily through the lens of food and culinary traditions. While this offers a unique and positive perspective, it potentially overshadows other crucial dimensions of the Palestinian struggle. The emphasis on chefs and food bloggers, although interesting, might inadvertently downplay the severity of the political and humanitarian crises. The headline (if one were to be constructed from the text) could be seen as framing the issue positively, focusing on resilience rather than oppression.
Language Bias
The language used is largely neutral and descriptive. However, phrases like "the most dangerous olive harvest of all time" and descriptions of intimidation and violence by Israeli settlers are emotionally charged and reflect a particular perspective. While these are likely accurate reflections of reported events, using more neutral language to describe the situation would improve objectivity. For example, instead of "intimidation and violence," one could use "reported incidents of harassment and physical altercations."
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the culinary aspects of Palestinian culture and the challenges faced by Palestinian farmers, but it omits discussion of other significant issues affecting Palestinians, such as political oppression, human rights violations, and the broader geopolitical context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. While the inclusion of the editor's warning about the impact of the war on the locations mentioned in the cookbook is a step towards acknowledging the wider conflict, a more thorough exploration of these issues would provide a more complete picture.
Gender Bias
The article mentions both male and female figures involved in Palestinian cuisine. Renad Attallah, a 10-year-old girl, is highlighted, showcasing a young generation's engagement with culinary traditions. This inclusion avoids gender stereotypes. However, a more in-depth analysis of gender roles in Palestinian society within the context of the conflict would enrich the piece.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article highlights the dangerous olive harvest season in the West Bank due to violence from Israeli settlers. This directly impacts food security and the livelihoods of Palestinian farmers, hindering their ability to produce and access food. The conflict also affects the availability of ingredients and the operation of food businesses, as indicated by the publisher's warning about possibly defunct locations mentioned in a cookbook featuring Palestinian recipes.