lexpress.fr
Zelensky: From Screen to Sacrifice
A new film depicts Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky's life, from his acting career in the TV series "Serviteur du peuple" to his presidency and assassination during Russia's invasion, highlighting parallels between the 1938 and 2024 Munich Conferences.
- What immediate impacts resulted from the blending of Zelensky's fictional presidential role and his real-life political career?
- Serviteur du peuple," a Ukrainian TV series starring Volodymyr Zelensky, depicts a history teacher unexpectedly becoming president. Its success propelled Zelensky into real-life politics, culminating in his 2019 election with 73% of the vote. A new film, previewed by the author, portrays Zelensky's presidency and its tragic end.
- How does the film's depiction of the 2024 Munich Conference reflect broader historical patterns of appeasement and their consequences?
- The film uses the Munich Conference of 2024 as a backdrop, drawing parallels to 1938 and highlighting how Western appeasement enabled Russia's invasion of Ukraine. The director-actor-president Zelensky's final scene mirrors Pinochet's attack on the Moneda Palace, but with a fatal outcome for Zelensky and his crew.
- What are the long-term implications of the film's ambiguous ending, and what critical perspectives does it raise regarding political leadership, international relations, and societal responsibility?
- The film's ending is left open, prompting reflection on collective responsibility. It serves as a stark warning against political complacency and the dangers of appeasement, suggesting a potential shift in geopolitical dynamics and a reevaluation of international relations.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The narrative framing strongly favors Zelensky and portrays him as a martyred hero. The language used, such as "martyr of the last European dream," is highly emotive and shapes the reader's perception. The comparison to Allende's fate further emphasizes this framing. The headline (if any) would likely reinforce this portrayal.
Language Bias
The review uses highly charged and emotional language, such as "cauchemar" (nightmare), "tordus" (twisted), and "martyre" (martyr), which heavily influences the reader's interpretation. The descriptions of the Russian soldiers' exclamations as "absurd" and the repeated rhetorical question "Comment avons-nous pu laisser faire ça?" (How could we have let this happen?) contribute to a biased tone. More neutral language would be needed for objective analysis.
Bias by Omission
The review focuses heavily on the filmmaker's perspective and the emotional impact of the film, potentially omitting counter-arguments or alternative interpretations of the events depicted. There is no mention of any critical reception besides the author's own. The historical context is presented through a highly selective lens, focusing on aspects that support the author's narrative and potentially neglecting other factors contributing to the conflict.
False Dichotomy
The review presents a stark dichotomy between Zelensky as a heroic figure and the Russian soldiers as villains. Nuances in the conflict are absent, and the narrative simplifies a complex geopolitical situation into a simplistic good vs. evil struggle.
Gender Bias
The review doesn't explicitly focus on gender, but the emphasis on Zelensky's heroic persona and the lack of attention to the experiences of Ukrainian women in the conflict could indicate a gender bias by omission. The analysis needs further exploration of the gender dynamics within the film itself.
Sustainable Development Goals
The film depicts the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine, highlighting the failure of international institutions to prevent the conflict and protect Ukraine's sovereignty. The quote "Comment avons-nous pu laisser faire ça?" ("How could we have let this happen?") encapsulates the film's central theme of questioning the international community's response to the escalating crisis and the breakdown of peace and security. The depiction of the invasion, the atrocities committed, and the lack of effective preventative measures directly relate to the lack of peace, justice, and strong institutions.