elpais.com
Basketball, Child Marriage, and Feminism in Shatila
Txell Feixas's book, "Aliadas," chronicles the transformative impact of Lebanon's first girls' youth basketball team in Beirut's Shatila refugee camp, highlighting its unexpected role in combating child marriage and promoting feminist ideals.
- What is the primary impact of creating Lebanon's first girls' youth basketball team in Shatila refugee camp?
- Aliadas", Txell Feixas's book, details the creation of Lebanon's first girls' youth basketball team in Shatila Palestinian refugee camp in 2012, highlighting its revolutionary impact on combating child marriage. The initiative, spearheaded by a father, Majdi, protecting his daughter, unexpectedly evolved into a feminist movement.
- How do economic factors and cultural beliefs contribute to child marriage in Lebanon, particularly in Shatila?
- Feixas's decade-long reporting reveals how child marriage, prevalent in Lebanon due to varying legal minimum ages across 18 religious communities (as low as nine years old for the Shia community), is often driven by poverty and cultural norms. Fathers, fearing for their daughters' safety in Shatila, sometimes see marriage as a solution, unaware of the resulting legal violation and vulnerability.
- What are the long-term implications of the basketball team's success in challenging social norms and promoting gender equality in Shatila and beyond?
- The book showcases the power of grassroots activism within a deeply patriarchal society, where even seemingly simple acts, like forming a basketball team, can disrupt established norms. By bridging the gap between Shatila and Beirut, the team fosters interfaith friendships, challenging stereotypes and raising awareness about child marriage, demonstrating a powerful alternative to ingrained cultural practices.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The narrative frames the story as an inspiring success story, focusing heavily on the positive impact of the basketball team. While this is a valid perspective, the framing might downplay the broader societal challenges and the ongoing struggle for gender equality in Lebanon. The headline (if there was one) and introduction would heavily influence this perception. The selection of quotes and the emphasis on the positive aspects of the project reinforce this framing.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the positive aspects of the women's basketball team and its impact, potentially omitting challenges or setbacks faced by the team or the broader feminist movement in Lebanon. While the author acknowledges the difficult conditions in Shatila, a more in-depth exploration of persistent obstacles and ongoing struggles would provide a more complete picture. The limitations of space are acknowledged, but further exploration of the complexities of the situation would enhance the article's impact.
False Dichotomy
The article doesn't present a clear false dichotomy, but it could benefit from acknowledging more nuanced perspectives on the role of religion and tradition in relation to women's rights in Lebanon. The author mentions some religious figures supporting the cause, but a more balanced discussion of the diverse viewpoints within religious communities would strengthen the analysis.
Gender Bias
The article centers the narrative around women's experiences and perspectives, which is commendable. However, it could benefit from a more explicit examination of the gender power dynamics within the families and community. While the author mentions fathers supporting the initiative, further analysis of their motivations and internal conflicts would provide a richer and more nuanced picture. The mention of veiling is handled with sensitivity, showing consideration for diverse perspectives and avoiding stereotypical portrayals.
Sustainable Development Goals
The book highlights a feminist revolution sparked by the creation of a girls basketball team in a Lebanese refugee camp, challenging child marriage and empowering girls through sports. The story showcases how a father's action to protect his daughter from child marriage transformed into a movement for gender equality, even within a challenging environment. The narrative also challenges stereotypes of Arab women and highlights the diverse experiences and activism within the region.