nrc.nl
Cleanliness as a Survival Strategy for Homeless Individuals in the Netherlands
Homeless individuals in Almere and Scheveningen maintain impeccably clean living spaces to avoid eviction, demonstrating resourcefulness and highlighting the precariousness of their situation, with an upcoming NATO summit potentially displacing many.
- How does the maintenance of cleanliness impact the relationship between homeless individuals and law enforcement or authorities?
- Homeless individuals are adopting cleanliness as a survival strategy to maintain their living spaces and avoid displacement by authorities. This is exemplified by the actions of both the individual in Almere and the couple in Scheveningen, who prioritize maintaining clean and organized living areas. This demonstrates how resourcefulness and proactive behavior are crucial for maintaining stability within unstable living situations.
- What survival strategies are homeless individuals employing to maintain their living spaces and avoid displacement by authorities?
- In Almere, a homeless individual meticulously cleaned their living area under a viaduct, a known drug dealing hotspot, to avoid authorities' intervention and maintain their residence. This mirrors a similar situation in Scheveningen, where a homeless couple, Rafael and Amee, maintain a meticulously clean and organized campsite to avoid eviction. Their actions highlight a survival strategy employed by the homeless to secure stable living conditions.
- What are the long-term implications for homeless individuals who maintain clean living spaces when faced with large-scale events or policy changes that necessitate relocation?
- The upcoming NATO summit in June will displace approximately thirty registered homeless individuals from Scheveningen's Bosjes, exposing the temporary nature of even carefully maintained homeless encampments and the vulnerability of homeless populations to political events and large-scale gatherings. The need for long-term solutions beyond maintaining a clean environment is highlighted by this forced displacement.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The narrative frames homelessness primarily through the lens of cleanliness and order. The headline (not provided) likely emphasizes this aspect, shaping the reader's perception of the issue. The opening anecdote highlights the cleaning efforts of a homeless individual, immediately setting the tone. This framing could lead readers to blame individuals for their homelessness, overlooking systemic causes.
Language Bias
The article uses language that could subtly reinforce negative stereotypes. Phrases like "crack dealers" and "prostitutes" create a harsh depiction of the environment, potentially reinforcing negative assumptions about homeless individuals. The repeated emphasis on cleanliness could be interpreted as judgmental. Neutral alternatives might include more descriptive phrases, such as individuals "exchanging goods" instead of "crack dealers", and focusing on the resourcefulness of the homeless people.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the cleanliness efforts of the homeless individuals, potentially omitting other crucial aspects of their lives and struggles, such as access to healthcare, mental health support, or job opportunities. The reasons for homelessness are largely unexplored, beyond the brief mention of one couple's circumstances. This omission might lead readers to focus solely on hygiene as the solution to homelessness, overlooking systemic issues.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a false dichotomy by suggesting that maintaining a clean living space is the primary solution to homelessness. While cleanliness is important, it ignores the complex societal and economic factors that contribute to homelessness.
Gender Bias
While both male and female perspectives are presented, there's a potential for gender bias in the descriptions. The article focuses on the woman's emotional state following her father's death, implying a vulnerability potentially not explored as deeply for the male perspective. More information about the roles and contributions of each partner would provide a more balanced portrayal.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article highlights a situation where homeless individuals maintain clean living spaces to avoid eviction and maintain stability. This directly relates to SDG 10 (Reduced Inequalities) by focusing on improving the living conditions and reducing vulnerabilities of marginalized groups. Maintaining a clean environment helps them avoid conflict with authorities and maintain a degree of security, which is crucial for social inclusion and reducing inequality.