dw.com
Cognac Faces Crisis Amidst Plummeting Chinese Exports and Tariff Threats
Facing a 50% drop in Chinese exports and threatened US tariffs, the French Cognac region, employing 70,000, grapples with its biggest crisis since the oil crisis, prompting calls for government intervention and internal adjustments like vineyard reduction.
- How are climate change and geopolitical factors affecting Cognac production and sales?
- The decline in Cognac sales is attributed to a confluence of factors: Chinese retaliatory tariffs (in response to EU tariffs on Chinese electric cars) halved sales to China, while threatened US tariffs of 200% on European alcohol add further pressure. These external factors compound existing challenges like climate change, which affects grape acidity, and the loss of the Russian market.
- What is the immediate economic impact of the sharp decline in Cognac exports to China and the threat of US tariffs?
- Cognac sales to China have plummeted by 50%, resulting in a monthly loss exceeding €50 million for the French Cognac region, impacting 70,000 jobs directly and indirectly. This is due to retaliatory tariffs imposed by China and the threat of similar tariffs from the US. The Cognac industry is facing its biggest crisis since the oil crisis.
- What long-term strategies are Cognac producers employing to adapt to the current challenges and ensure the industry's future?
- The Cognac industry's response to this crisis includes calls for government aid and internal adjustments such as reducing vineyard size to cut costs. However, some producers, like Alain Reboul, resist downsizing their vineyards, highlighting the generational commitment involved and the uncertainty of alternative crops. The industry is also exploring diversification strategies and marketing approaches to attract younger consumers.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The narrative frames the challenges faced by Cognac producers as a significant crisis, highlighting the potential for job losses and economic downturn. The use of phrases like "maior choque desde a crise do petróleo" (biggest shock since the oil crisis) and the emphasis on the decrease in sales to China strongly emphasizes the negative aspects of the situation. While it includes some positive notes, such as the resilience of some producers and the continuing appeal of Cognac, the overall framing leans towards a pessimistic outlook.
Language Bias
The language used is generally neutral, but the repeated emphasis on negative consequences and the use of phrases like "maior choque" (biggest shock) contribute to a somewhat dramatic tone. While factually accurate, this choice of language may intensify the negative perception of the situation. The article could benefit from using more balanced language that highlights both challenges and positive adaptations.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the challenges faced by Cognac producers due to geopolitical factors and climate change, but it omits discussion of potential solutions or innovations within the industry beyond adapting to climate change by using different grape varieties. While it mentions the BNIC's appeal to the French government, it doesn't explore other potential responses from the industry itself, such as diversification into new markets or product lines beyond the scope mentioned. The article also lacks information on the social and economic impact of the downturn on the workers within the industry beyond a mention of 70,000 jobs.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a somewhat false dichotomy between continuing traditional practices (planting more vines) and adapting to market changes (removing vines). While it acknowledges the complexities of the situation through Reboul's perspective, the narrative subtly pushes toward the idea that adaptation might be necessary, neglecting other potential solutions that don't involve drastically changing production practices.
Gender Bias
The article features two main characters: Alain Reboul and Cassandra Allary. While both are presented as successful business owners, the descriptions of their work differ slightly. Reboul's story is framed within the larger context of Cognac production and its economic challenges, while Allary's is more focused on the detailed craftsmanship of barrel-making. This difference could be seen as subtly reinforcing traditional gender roles: Reboul as the businessman dealing with large-scale issues and Allary as the craftsperson focused on detailed work. However, without further information, this conclusion would be speculative.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article highlights a significant decline in Cognac sales due to trade disputes and economic factors, leading to job losses and economic hardship in the region. The decrease in demand has forced some producers to uproot vines and consider alternative crops, impacting the livelihoods of many involved in the Cognac industry, from grape growers to barrel makers.