dw.com
EU's State of the Union Address: Focus on Latin America and Global Competition
In her State of the Union address on September 10, 2025, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen emphasized Europe's need for strategic alliances with Latin American countries like Mexico and Mercosur members to secure its independence amidst global competition.
- How does the EU's pursuit of these alliances relate to its broader economic and geopolitical strategies?
- The EU's focus on Latin America reflects its competition with China and Russia for resources and its need to secure its supply chains. The "made in Europe" initiative, incentivizing the use of European products in Global Gateway projects, further underscores this strategy. These actions also highlight EU's ambition to reshape global trade rules to its advantage.
- What are the key strategic alliances the EU is pursuing in Latin America, and what are their immediate implications?
- The EU seeks stronger economic and political ties with Mexico and Mercosur, focusing on clean energy, electric vehicles, AI, and energy infrastructure. This includes safeguards and compensation funds for European farmers impacted by increased imports from Mercosur under their trade agreement. The EU also aims to reform the global trade system through a coalition similar to CPTPP, including Chile, Mexico, and Peru.
- What are the potential criticisms of the EU's approach, particularly regarding human rights and environmental concerns in Latin America?
- Critics argue that the EU's pursuit of economic interests prioritizes corporate gains over human rights and environmental protection. The streamlining of regulations, such as delaying deforestation regulations and weakening due diligence rules, raises concerns about increased extractivism and human rights violations in partner countries. The EU's stance on asylum and migration, deeming countries like Colombia "safe," despite ongoing conflicts, also faces sharp criticism.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The speech focuses heavily on the EU's economic interests and its competition with other global powers, framing its relationship with Latin America through this lens. The emphasis on securing resources and markets for European businesses overshadows other potential aspects of the relationship, such as development cooperation or human rights. For example, the discussion of Mercosur focuses on its economic benefits for the EU and the safeguards to protect European farmers, rather than on the potential benefits for the Mercosur countries themselves. The 'made in Europe' initiative is presented as a key priority, suggesting a prioritization of European interests over potential partnerships built on mutual benefit.
Language Bias
The language used tends to be descriptive of EU actions and policies from a positive perspective, while presenting criticisms of the EU's actions with more negative connotations. For example, the concerns of environmental and human rights organizations are described as a 'hard blow,' while the business sector's approval is presented neutrally. The term 'extractivism' is used repeatedly to describe the EU's actions in Latin America, carrying a negative connotation and suggesting an exploitative relationship.
Bias by Omission
The analysis omits a comprehensive overview of the EU's relationship with all of Latin America and the Caribbean. While Mexico and Mercosur are mentioned prominently, other countries and regional organizations are largely ignored. The potential benefits of cooperation beyond economic considerations, such as cultural exchange or humanitarian assistance, are not explored. The text also omits details about specific agreements and their implications.
False Dichotomy
The speech presents a simplified view of the EU's relationship with the rest of the world, presenting a dichotomy between the EU, its allies (Mexico, Mercosur), and its competitors (China, Russia). The complexities of these relationships and the presence of diverse viewpoints within each region are not sufficiently addressed. The focus on 'made in Europe' initiatives creates a false dichotomy between European products and those from other countries, potentially hindering true cooperation.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article highlights how the EU's focus on its own competitiveness, through measures like the omnibus regulations, may negatively impact developing countries in Latin America. The prioritization of European interests, including "made in Europe" initiatives and stricter asylum policies, could exacerbate existing inequalities and limit opportunities for Latin American nations. The weakening of labor rights protections and environmental regulations in the name of economic competitiveness directly contradicts efforts to reduce inequalities globally.