nrc.nl
Good One": A coming-of-age hike revealing damaged trust
In India Donaldson's directorial debut "Good One", 17-year-old Sam, her father Chris, and Chris's friend Matt, hike the Catskill Mountains; the trip reveals the men's flaws, impacting Sam's trust and forcing her into a premature adulthood.
- How do the specific scenes involving Sam using a tampon contribute to the overall themes of the film?
- The film uses Sam's experience to explore themes of sexism and the erosion of trust. The subtle yet impactful scenes involving Sam using a tampon illustrate her diminishing sense of safety and privacy as she navigates the trip with her father and Matt. The men's actions, though sometimes unintentional, demonstrate a lack of consideration for Sam's needs and boundaries.
- What are the potential long-term consequences of this experience on Sam's relationships and outlook on life?
- Good One" suggests a lasting impact on Sam's worldview. The events of the hike, particularly Matt's comment by the campfire and the recurring tampon scenes, mark a significant shift in her perception of men and her loss of innocence. This suggests a future where she approaches relationships with increased caution and a heightened awareness of power dynamics.
- What immediate impact do the men's actions have on Sam's emotional state and sense of safety during the hiking trip?
- Good One" follows 17-year-old Sam on a three-day hike in New York's Catskill Mountains with her father, Chris, and Chris's friend, Matt. While Chris is meticulously prepared, Matt is disorganized, leading to friction between the men. The film beautifully captures the natural landscape and focuses on Sam's perspective, highlighting her observations and reactions to the men's behavior.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The narrative is framed entirely through Sam's perspective. The film and review use Sam's reactions and experiences as the primary lens for evaluating the events and characters. This focus, while effective in conveying Sam's emotional journey, creates a framing bias, potentially overlooking other interpretations and perspectives.
Language Bias
The language used is largely descriptive and avoids overtly loaded terms. However, terms such as "egocentric" and "sexistisch" (sexist) suggest a critical viewpoint toward the male characters, while Sam's perspective is presented with more sympathy. While these terms describe the situation, more neutral language could be used for more objective analysis.
Bias by Omission
The review focuses heavily on Sam's experience and doesn't offer much insight into the perspectives of Chris or Matt beyond their actions towards Sam. The motivations and internal struggles of the male characters are largely unexplored, potentially omitting valuable context to their behavior. While the film's focus is on Sam, a more balanced perspective might have enriched the analysis.
False Dichotomy
The review suggests a false dichotomy between Sam's innocence and her sudden loss of it, implying a simplistic transition to adulthood. The complexities of growing up and the gradual erosion of trust are simplified into a singular event triggered by Matt's comment. The nuanced aspects of adolescence and emotional development are underrepresented.
Gender Bias
The review highlights instances of sexism, focusing on the men's behavior towards Sam and framing it within a narrative of her loss of innocence. The review effectively illustrates how seemingly small actions reflect larger gender dynamics, especially how the men's actions impact Sam's sense of safety and autonomy. However, it would benefit from a discussion about whether the male characters are deliberately malicious or if their behavior stems from unconscious biases.
Sustainable Development Goals
The film depicts subtle instances of sexism and the erosion of a young woman's safe space, highlighting the challenges women face in navigating gender dynamics and unequal power relations. The narrative focuses on how the actions of the men impact Sam's sense of safety and security, demonstrating a negative impact on gender equality.