nrc.nl
Knausgård's "Het derde rijk": Supernatural Events and Ordinary Lives
In Karl Ove Knausgård's "Het derde rijk," the third book in the "Morgenster" series, strange events following a new star's appearance in Norway continue, including impossible revivals and ritualistic murders, while ordinary life proceeds alongside these supernatural occurrences.
- What are the immediate, specific impacts of the new star's appearance on the lives of ordinary Norwegians as depicted in "Het derde rijk"?
- In Karl Ove Knausgård's "Het derde rijk," the third installment of his "Morgenster" series, strange occurrences continue following the appearance of a new star: mass crab migrations, insect infestations, and medically impossible instances of revived brain activity. Four of five black metal band members are ritually murdered in an impossible manner. This follows the previous volumes which explored similar events through different narratives.
- What are the potential long-term implications of the narrative's unresolved plotlines and shifts in narrative style on the overarching themes and coherence of the "Morgenster" series?
- The novel's less convincing aspects, such as clichéd detective work and unconvincing romantic developments, detract from its overall impact. The ending, particularly Tove's storyline involving flying demons, sharply contrasts with Knausgård's established style, raising questions about the series' direction and the author's ability to maintain narrative coherence. The open-ended nature of the narrative may necessitate the completion of the series for full comprehension and assessment.
- How does Knausgård's portrayal of everyday life contrast with the extraordinary events surrounding the new star, and what commentary does this offer on human resilience and adaptation?
- Knausgård's work explores the juxtaposition of ordinary life with extraordinary events, mirroring societal responses during crises like the COVID-19 pandemic. Characters grapple with mundane issues alongside the inexplicable, demonstrating humanity's adaptation to extraordinary circumstances. The narrative shifts between multiple viewpoints, highlighting the subjective nature of reality and its construction through individual perspectives.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The review frames the book negatively, highlighting its perceived flaws and inconsistencies. The choice of words like "banality," "cliché," and "slordig" (sloppy) sets a critical and somewhat dismissive tone from the start. The emphasis on the book's shortcomings compared to Knausgård's previous work influences the reader's perception.
Language Bias
The review uses loaded language such as "banal," "clichéd," "slordig" (sloppy), "Netflix-achtig" (Netflix-like), and "bizar" (bizarre) to describe aspects of the book, shaping the reader's perception negatively. More neutral alternatives could include "conventional," "predictable," "unpolished," "formulaic," and "unusual." The frequent use of negative descriptors reveals an implicit negative bias.
Bias by Omission
The review focuses heavily on the author's writing style and choices, potentially overlooking other critical aspects of the book, such as its thematic elements or cultural impact. The analysis mentions the Nazi connotations of the title but doesn't delve into it deeply. There's also a lack of discussion on the broader reception of the book beyond the reviewer's personal opinions.
False Dichotomy
The review presents a dichotomy between 'banality' and 'genre-literature' versus the author's previous works, suggesting a simplistic view of the book's potential complexities and literary merit. It frames the choice of themes as either a return to form or a betrayal of the author's previous styles, which may be an oversimplification.
Gender Bias
The review analyzes the portrayal of female characters, noting inconsistencies in their development and motivations. However, it does not explicitly analyze the gender representation within the narrative structure or broader themes. While the review focuses on specific female characters' experiences, a wider analysis of gender dynamics within the novel is missing.