nrc.nl
Mama wil weg": A Daughter's Reckoning with Suicide and Societal Pressures
Mirjam van Biemen's "Mama wil weg" reconstructs her mother's life and suicide through diaries and interviews, revealing the struggles of a woman with journalistic aspirations in a patriarchal society, raising questions about consent and societal pressures on women and mental health.
- How does the author's personal journey of reconstructing her mother's life shape the narrative and its potential impact on readers?
- The book highlights the challenges faced by women in the past century, balancing career ambitions with motherhood and navigating abusive relationships. Rieneke's story exemplifies the systemic barriers faced by women striving for professional fulfillment and the societal attitudes towards mental health issues. The diary entries provide intimate details that create a powerful, moving narrative.
- What systemic factors contributed to Rieneke's struggles and eventual suicide, and what does her story reveal about societal attitudes toward women and mental health in the past?
- Mama wil weg" by Mirjam van Biemen recounts her mother Rieneke's life, culminating in suicide. Rieneke, a woman with journalistic aspirations hindered by societal constraints and a violent marriage, left behind diary entries forming the book's core. Mirjam explores her mother's struggles, aiming to understand her life and death.
- What are the ethical considerations surrounding the publication of this intimate account, considering the lack of consent from the deceased and the potential impact on family members?
- The book raises questions about consent and the ethics of publishing intimate details of a deceased parent's life. The impact of past trauma and societal expectations on mental health is central. It invites reflection on how personal narratives can serve both personal healing and broader societal understanding, but also the potential ethical conflicts inherent in such undertakings. The author's choice to publish despite potential conflicts adds another layer of complexity.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The review frames the book as a deeply personal story with broader societal implications. While acknowledging the intensely private nature of the events, it also highlights the book's relevance to women's struggles in the past century and issues within mental health care. The emphasis shifts between the personal narrative and its broader symbolic significance.
Language Bias
The language used is largely neutral and descriptive. Words like "aangrijpend" (gripping) and "spannend" (exciting) are used, but these are generally appropriate descriptors for the subject matter. No obviously loaded language is detected.
Bias by Omission
The review mentions the author's sister's reluctance to share details of their family's past, suggesting a potential bias by omission regarding the full extent of the family's experiences and perspectives. The review also notes that a psychiatrist refused to provide information, implying potentially relevant details might be missing.
Gender Bias
The analysis focuses on a female protagonist's struggles within a patriarchal society, which is presented as a common experience of women during that time. This doesn't inherently exhibit gender bias, but rather uses a specific case to illustrate a broader societal issue.
Sustainable Development Goals
The book explores the challenges faced by women in the past century, highlighting the difficulties they encountered in balancing career aspirations with societal expectations and domestic responsibilities. The author's mother's struggle to pursue her journalistic ambitions while raising a family reflects the broader systemic barriers women faced in achieving professional success. The narrative implicitly advocates for greater gender equality and supports the empowerment of women to pursue their goals without facing undue limitations.