elmundo.es
Pegasus Spyware Infected Aide to Puigdemont's Phone: 3.2 GB of Data Stolen
A Mossos d'Esquadra report confirms Pegasus spyware infected Josep Lluís Alay's iPhone 8 from October 11, 2019, to summer 2020, stealing 3.2 GB of data; another phone showed a malicious text but no infection; the report was submitted to a Barcelona court following a complaint by Alay.
- What specific evidence confirms the Pegasus spyware infection of Josep Lluís Alay's phone, and what data was compromised?
- A report by the Mossos d'Esquadra reveals that Josep Lluís Alay's iPhone 8 was infected with Pegasus spyware from October 11, 2019, to summer 2020, resulting in the theft of 3.2 gigabytes of data. Another phone, a Xiaomi Redmi Go, showed evidence of a malicious text message, but it was not opened. This information comes from an October 2024 forensic analysis report submitted to a Barcelona court.
- How does the timing of the Pegasus infection, starting in October 2019, relate to the Spanish government's actions and statements regarding surveillance?
- The infection of Alay's phone with Pegasus spyware, confirmed by a Mossos d'Esquadra report, is linked to the ongoing Catalangate scandal involving surveillance of Catalan politicians and activists. The timing, beginning in October 2019 under Interior Minister Fernando Grande-Marlaska, raises questions about governmental oversight and potential abuse of power. The 3.2 GB data theft highlights the severity of the breach.
- What are the long-term implications of this case for the security and privacy of political figures and activists in Spain, and what reforms are needed to prevent similar incidents?
- This case underscores the potential for widespread abuse of spyware technology against political opponents. The fact that the infection went undetected for months and resulted in a significant data breach raises serious concerns about the security of personal devices and the need for stronger oversight of government surveillance practices. Future investigations should focus on identifying the source of the infection and holding those responsible accountable.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The headline and opening sentences immediately focus on the positive finding for Puigdemont (Pegasus infection confirmed). The article structures the information to highlight the alleged government misconduct first, then mentions the lack of evidence on the second phone later, potentially shaping the reader's perception towards confirming Puigdemont's accusations. The quotes from Puigdemont and Boye are prominently featured, further reinforcing the narrative of government wrongdoing.
Language Bias
While generally factual, the article uses emotionally charged language, such as "ensuciar la reputación" (to dirty the reputation) and phrases like "ultraderecha policial y judicial" (far-right police and judicial). These choices lean towards supporting Puigdemont's accusations rather than maintaining strict neutrality. Neutral alternatives could include more descriptive and less judgmental language such as "damaged reputation" and "elements within the police and judicial system.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the findings of the Mossos d'Esquadra report and the reactions of Puigdemont and his lawyer, Boye. However, it omits potential counterarguments or explanations from the government regarding the alleged surveillance. The article also doesn't delve into the specifics of the "operation Voloh" beyond its connection to Alay's phone seizure. While space constraints likely play a role, the lack of these perspectives limits a fully informed understanding of the situation.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a somewhat simplistic dichotomy between Puigdemont's claims of political persecution and the government's potential denials (implied, not explicitly stated). The nuance of legal processes and potential complexities within the Spanish government's actions are largely absent.
Gender Bias
The article focuses primarily on male figures (Puigdemont, Alay, Grande-Marlaska, Boye, Aragonès). While this may reflect the individuals involved in the case, it lacks a broader perspective of gender dynamics and influence in the political climate. There is no overt gender bias in language used.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article highlights the use of Pegasus spyware to spy on Josep Lluís Alay, chief of staff to Carles Puigdemont. This action undermines democratic institutions, violates privacy rights, and potentially obstructs justice. The quote from Carles Puigdemont referencing the continued use of undemocratic practices further emphasizes this negative impact on institutions. The fact that the spyware was used during the time of a specific interior minister raises questions about accountability and oversight within governmental bodies.