dw.com
German Court Ruling Impacts Russian Draft Dodger Asylum
A German court ruling regarding asylum for a Chechen criminal sets a concerning precedent for Russian draft dodgers, impacting their asylum applications and potentially increasing deportations.
Ukrainian
Germany
RussiaGermany Russia Ukraine WarRefugees And MigrationDeportationAsylumCourt Ruling
DwTagesschau.deConnectionSolidarusMovement Of Conscious Refuseniks
Mersad SmajicRudi FriedrichRobin WagenerArtem KligaAlexey Kozlov
- What is the concern among Russian draft dodgers and those supporting them regarding this court ruling?
- The decision is causing concern among Russian draft dodgers and those helping them. Some organizations are advising against seeking asylum in Germany due to the increased likelihood of deportation and the court's interpretation of the risk faced by conscripts.
- How has the German government reacted to this ruling, and what is the conflict with the court's assessment?
- The German government's coordinator for cooperation with Moldova, the South Caucasus, and Central Asia criticized the ruling, emphasizing that poorly trained conscripts are indeed sent to war. This highlights a conflict between the court's assessment and the reality on the ground.
- What is the main impact of the recent Berlin court ruling on Russian draft dodgers seeking asylum in Germany?
- A recent Berlin court ruling could significantly impact Russian draft dodgers seeking asylum in Germany. The court rejected the appeal of a Chechen criminal, arguing that conscripts are not deployed to combat zones, setting a potential precedent for future cases.
- Why did the court reject the asylum claim of the Chechen criminal, even though he cited the risk of being drafted?
- The ruling, while concerning a Chechen criminal, not a draft dodger, establishes that the threat of deployment to Ukraine is insufficient grounds for asylum. This is because conscripts from regions other than Chechnya are not typically sent to the combat zones.
- What is the significance of this ruling in terms of legal precedent in Germany, and how does it affect the prospects of Russian draft dodgers?
- While German law doesn't have a strict precedent system, this higher court ruling is influencing other courts, potentially setting a de facto precedent. This makes asylum significantly less attainable for Russian draft dodgers, increasing the risk of deportation.