dw.com
German Court Ruling Impacts Russian Draft Evaders
A German court ruling against a Chechen man's deportation appeal may set a precedent impacting hundreds of Russian draft evaders seeking asylum. The court argued that conscripts aren't deployed to combat zones, a claim disputed by some.
Russian
Germany
RussiaGermany Russia Ukraine WarRefugeesRefugees And MigrationAsylumCourt Decision
Berlin-Brandenburg Higher Administrative CourtConnection (Ngo)DwSolidarusMovement Of Conscious Refusers
Mersad SmajicRudi FriedrichRobin WagenerArtem KlygaAlexey Kozlov
- What initiated the legal case that led to the recent court decision?
- The case began with a 22-year-old Chechen criminal's appeal against deportation from Germany. He argued that deportation would lead to conscription and deployment to Ukraine, a claim the court rejected.
- What arguments did the court use to reject the appeal of the Chechen man?
- The court's decision meticulously analyzed conscription practices in Russia, concluding that conscripts are not sent to combat zones and that even Chechens are called up under standard procedures. The court also noted that deported individuals can choose their residence within Russia.
- What is the potential impact of the court's decision on Russian draft dodgers seeking asylum in Germany?
- The Berlin-Brandenburg Higher Administrative Court's decision, while not setting legal precedent in Germany, is highly influential and may impact hundreds of Russian draft evaders seeking refugee status. Lower courts may follow suit, creating a de facto precedent.
- What are the different perspectives of human rights organizations and government officials on the court's ruling?
- Human rights organizations and some German officials disagree with the court ruling, arguing that the decision ignores the reality of conscripts being sent to war and the risk they face. They contend the decision will harm draft evaders seeking refuge.
- What is the current trend regarding deportations from Germany to Russia and the success rate of asylum applications by Russian men?
- The number of deportations from Germany to Russia is increasing, raising concerns about the safety of those deported. Furthermore, only a tiny percentage of asylum applications by Russian men of fighting age have been approved.